DecodedCarsBMW X4 vs Tesla Model Y
2025 BMW X4 vs 2025 Tesla Model Y — two small SUVs compared on efficiency, size, safety and reliability.
The short version
That works out to about $2,800 a year less in fuel for the Tesla Model Y (EPA estimate, 15,000 miles).
Across all model years since 2005, the BMW X4 has had fewer recall campaigns (28 vs 43).
The two cars
The 2025 BMW X4 is a small SUV offered with 2 engines (2.0L 4-cyl turbo and 3.0L 6-cyl turbo), including a hybrid version and all-wheel drive. It measures about 187 inches long and 76 inches wide on a 113-inch wheelbase, with a curb weight of roughly 4,323 lb (M40i 4dr SUV).
The 2025 Tesla Model Y is a small SUV powered by electricity and rear-wheel drive and all-wheel drive. It measures about 189 inches long and 78 inches wide on a 114-inch wheelbase, with a curb weight of roughly 4,363 lb.
Buying used? The 2024 X4 and the 2024 Model Y have the fewest problems in our data; avoid the 2020 X4 and the 2023 Model Y.
Basics
Efficiency
Performance & space
Safety & reliability
Interest
Green = clearly better. Prices are not included. How we calculate this →
Which one should you choose?
Choose the BMW X4 if…
- You put reliability history first (28 vs 43 recalls since 2005)
Choose the Tesla Model Y if…
- You want an EV with more range (337 miles)
Pros & cons of each
2025 BMW X4
- Hybrid version availableOffered as a hybrid as well as gas.
- Premium fuel requiredEvery gasoline version is rated for premium, which raises running costs.
- Modest powerUp to 248 hp, versus about 335 hp for similar 2025 models.
2025 Tesla Model Y
- Long EV rangeUp to 337 miles on a charge (EPA).
- AWD / 4WD available
- 5-star NHTSA safety ratingTop overall score in federal crash tests.
- Lots of standard safety tech5 of 5 key driver aids standard on the versions we checked.
- Many owner complaints109 complaints filed with NHTSA versus about 6 for similar models — most often about the forward collision avoidance: adaptive cruise control.
Full 2025 BMW X4 specs →Full 2025 Tesla Model Y specs →Compare fuel costs for your driving →Compare size & garage fit →